The history of the death penalty in Russia
The article examines the development of the death penalty in Russian law from the early written legal sources to the contemporary moratorium. It considers the grounds and methods of capital punishment in the Pskov Judicial Charter and the Sudebnik of 1497, the expansion of its use under Peter I, and the subsequent restrictions introduced during the reigns of Catherine II and Paul I. Particular attention is paid to the changing legal framework in the Soviet period, including the abolition of 1947 and the restoration of capital punishment in 1950. The final part analyses the constitutional and international legal grounds for the non-application of the death penalty in modern Russia. The historical review shows that the scope of this punishment was closely connected with the political and legal priorities of each period, while its effectiveness as a means of preventing crime remains debatable.
death penalty, capital punishment, history of Russian law, criminal punishment, moratorium, human rights, constitutional law.
1.Introduction
Many researchers associate the emergence of the death penalty with the period when criminal justice came under state control: punishable acts began to be defined with greater legislative precision, and the authority to impose punishment became the exclusive prerogative of the central state. The death penalty has remained a relevant subject throughout history and continues to provoke debate. For centuries, its humanity and morality have been contested. In his work On Crimes and Punishments (1764), Cesare Beccaria argued that by entering society, a person does not surrender the right to their own life; therefore, the state has no right to execute them [1]. Mably and Jiry defended the opposite position, also relying on natural-law theory. Mably reasoned that in the state of nature a person has the right to take the life of someone who threatens their own, and that upon entering society this right is merely transferred to the judge. Another author added that in a state of natural independence a person may kill an unjust aggressor, who thereby forfeits the right to life; society does not create a new right but exercises an existing one, taking the place of the individual when imposing the death penalty. No consensus on capital punishment has emerged in modern society. This article examines the history of the death penalty in Russia in order to trace its development through different historical periods and consider how effective this punishment has been.
2.Materials and Methods
The study is based on a historical-legal and formal-legal analysis of Russian normative acts, including the Pskov Judicial Charter, the Sudebnik of 1497, the Military Article of 1715, Soviet criminal legislation and contemporary constitutional decisions. The comparative-historical method is used to identify changes in the grounds and limits of capital punishment across different periods. The analysis also draws on historical and legal scholarship cited in the references. The research is limited to the development of the institution in Russia; it does not attempt to provide a comprehensive comparative study of foreign legislation.
The Pre-Moscow and Early Moscow Period
The first written reference to the death penalty in Russian law appears in the Pskov Judicial Charter [3]. Its provisions on capital punishment are concentrated in two articles. Article 7 prescribed execution for four offences: the robbery of the Pskov Kremlin, where the state treasury, archival documents and grain supplies were kept; horse theft; treason, understood as joining the enemy; and arson. Article 8 introduced the death penalty for repeated theft. A thief caught for the first or second time could be pardoned and required to pay a fine to the prince, whereas a third offence was punishable by death. Thus, the Charter did not restrict capital punishment to the offences listed in Article 7; it also extended it to habitual thieves, treating recidivism as evidence of particular danger to society. The Charter did not specify methods of execution, using only a general formula. Drawing on chronicle accounts, historians conventionally distinguish between ordinary forms of execution, such as hanging and beheading, and aggravated forms, such as burning, which was especially painful. The Charter did not establish a direct link between a particular offence and a method of execution. However, chronicles suggest that arsonists were usually burned, thieves were hanged or burned, and traitors were executed by order of the veche, or popular assembly. Executions were public and intended to intimidate the population and provide reparation for the harm caused. No consolidated statistics on the number of people executed in the fifteenth century have survived; chronicles record only individual high-profile cases. One such episode dates to 1469. Livonian knights, together with the Chud people, raided Pskov territory despite an existing peace agreement. According to the Pskov First Chronicle, the traitors Ivanko Podkursky and Ivanko Torgosha showed the attackers the way. Their actions were classified as high treason, for which the Charter prescribed the death penalty. The people of Pskov passed sentence without a lengthy trial: Podkursky was tortured by being tied to a log, while Torgosha was hanged upside down by his feet on the ice. The execution was public and intended to serve as a warning [4].
The next significant legal act to mention the death penalty was the Sudebnik of Ivan III of 1497 [5]. Several of its articles expressly provided for capital punishment. Article 8 prescribed execution for a “notorious criminal” found guilty of theft, robbery, murder, malicious slander or another serious offence. The offender’s property was to be used to compensate the victims; if the offender had no property, the execution was carried out by an official of the princely court. Article 9 contained the principal list of offences punishable by death: the murder of one’s master, high treason, theft from a church, theft accompanied by murder or abduction, incitement to rebellion, bringing a false accusation and arson. Article 11 established the death penalty for repeated theft, following the approach of Article 8 of the Pskov Judicial Charter: the first theft was punishable by a fine and the second by death. Article 13 provided for capital punishment when a thief was caught in the act and five or six reputable people confirmed under oath that the person had committed theft before. Article 39 required local authorities to transfer such offenders to the central authorities and prohibited them from carrying out executions independently. Other provisions were indirectly related to capital punishment: Article 14 allowed torture to be used against a person identified by a captured thief, while Article 43 prohibited local judges from executing thieves and murderers without approval from a higher authority, thereby placing the use of this punishment under state control [5]. The Sudebnik itself did not specify methods of execution, limiting itself to the formula “to be punished by death.” Chronicles provide evidence of actual practice: beheading, quartering, hanging, burning (including in wooden structures and cages) and drowning were used. Beheading was considered the least dishonourable method, while particularly painful forms were reserved for traitors and heretics. Chronicles preserve accounts of several high-profile cases. For example, Prince Ivan Lukomsky and Matthias, who were accused of plotting to kill Ivan III, were burned in a cage outside the Kremlin in the presence of the Grand Prince and a large crowd. This is the earliest reliably documented instance of this form of execution in Moscow. Another example was the persecution of followers of the Novgorod-Moscow heresy. In Moscow, Ivan Volk Kuritsyn and Dmitry Konoplyov were executed; in Veliky Novgorod, the victims included Nekras Rukavov, whose tongue had first been torn out, the Archimandrite of Yuriev Monastery Kassian, his brother Ivan Samochyorny and others. They were burned in specially constructed wooden enclosures to conceal their agony from the public . No consolidated statistics on executions under the Sudebnik have survived; chronicles record only individual notorious cases.
The Imperial Period
A new stage in the development of the death penalty is associated with the imperial period and, above all, with Peter I’s Military Article of 1715 [6]. This act substantially expanded the range of offences punishable by death: capital punishment became a key instrument for maintaining military discipline and deterring the population. Desertion from the battlefield and unauthorized absence from a garrison or military convoy, as well as transferring to another regiment without permission, were punishable by hanging. Premeditated murder was punishable by beheading, while suicide was treated as equivalent to murder: the body of a person who had taken their own life was dragged through the streets and buried in a dishonourable place. Particularly severe forms of execution, including quartering, breaking on the wheel and burning, were prescribed for offences against the state and religion, such as treason, insulting the monarch, rebellion and blasphemy. The death penalty was also applied to economic and property offences, including counterfeiting, arson and theft above a specified value. A special form was execution in absentia, for example, for defecting to the enemy. The offender’s name was nailed to the gallows, their property was confiscated, and, if captured, they were executed without a new trial. This procedure was used, among others, against Hetman Ivan Mazepa. Despite the severity of its provisions, the Military Article allowed the circumstances of a case to be taken into account. Certain categories of people, including women, infants, clergymen and elderly people, could also be exempted from execution unless the high command ordered otherwise. Thus, the Military Article reflected the logic of an absolutist state in which capital punishment became a systematic instrument of control and intimidation, regulated in detail to meet the needs of the regular army and strengthen state power. No unified central statistics were kept on executions under the Military Article. A figure of approximately 799 people is sometimes cited in the literature, although it does not refer exclusively to executions under this act and instead relates to particular campaigns of repression. Large-scale executions were recorded in connection with the suppression of major uprisings: more than a thousand musketeers were executed after the Streltsy uprising of 1698, around 320 people after the Astrakhan uprising of 1705, and approximately 200 after Kondraty Bulavin’s rebellion in 1708. In practice, the death penalty was often commuted to exile or hard labour [7].
The approach to capital punishment changed considerably during the reigns of Catherine II and Paul I. Catherine, who presented herself as an enlightened monarch, took a highly restrained view of the death penalty. In her Instruction, she questioned the usefulness of this punishment and considered it permissible only in exceptional circumstances [2]. In practice, it was used mainly in high-profile cases involving state crimes: the execution of Lieutenant Vasily Mirovich in 1764; the executions of those involved in the murder of Archbishop Ambrosius during the Moscow Plague Riot of 1771; and the execution of Yemelyan Pugachev in 1775. Pugachev was initially sentenced to be quartered for organizing a large-scale rebellion and impersonating the emperor, but Catherine II secretly instructed the executioner to behead him first in order to shorten his suffering. According to historians’ estimates, approximately 40–50 people were executed during Catherine II’s entire reign, mostly in political cases [7]. Paul I went even further: he refused in principle to approve death sentences. He is known to have said: “Thank God, there is no death penalty in Russia, and it is not for me to introduce it.” The emperor extended this approach to newly annexed territories, prohibiting the use of capital punishment in all lands incorporated into the empire during his reign. Whereas under Peter I the death penalty was a widespread and carefully regulated instrument of state control, accompanied by waves of repression in response to uprisings and rebellions, Catherine II and Paul I consciously restricted its use. This change reflected an evolution in legal policy, from severe deterrence towards attempts to humanize justice and reduce state violence [7].
The Soviet Period
Until 1950, the Soviet Union’s approach to the death penalty was contradictory and largely reflected the political objectives of the state. Immediately after the 1917 Revolution, capital punishment was officially abolished. However, by 1918, during the Civil War and the period of the Red Terror, it was being actively used, including outside the ordinary judicial process. In 1922, the first Criminal Code of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic was adopted. For the first time, it established a detailed list of offences punishable by death: counter-revolutionary acts, including uprisings, espionage and terrorist attacks; offences against public administration, such as banditry and mass disorder; military offences, particularly during wartime; and certain official and property-related offences [8]. In the same year, the execution of minors under the age of 18 and pregnant women was prohibited. The use of the death penalty expanded sharply during the 1930s. It reached its peak during the Great Terror of 1937–1938, when more than 681,000 death sentences were issued in cases handled by the People’s Commissariat for Internal Affairs. Extrajudicial bodies, known as “troikas,” and the Special Council played an important role, issuing decisions without full judicial proceedings. In 1935, a decree was adopted allowing any criminal punishment, including the death penalty, to be imposed on minors from the age of 12. This provision remained in force until 1947. During the Second World War, the death penalty was also widely used, including for aiding the enemy; hanging was sometimes used as well. After the war, on 26 May 1947, the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR issued the decree “On the Abolition of the Death Penalty,” stating that capital punishment would not be applied in peacetime [9]. Historians note the political nature of this decision: it was presented as an act of humanism and as a response to the wishes of trade unions and the public. The decree had retroactive effect and saved people who had already been sentenced to death from execution. However, on 12 January 1950, the death penalty was restored by the decree “On the Application of the Death Penalty to Traitors to the Motherland, Spies and Saboteurs” [10]. Soviet publications explained the decision by referring to “numerous requests from workers,” while researchers associate it with the intensification of the Cold War and new repressive campaigns, such as the Leningrad Affair. A resolution of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) allowed the death penalty to be applied to people who had committed such offences between 1947 and 1950. In other words, the law was given retroactive effect, an exceptional measure. The decree covered three categories of offences: treason against the Motherland, meaning actions undermining state security; espionage, meaning the collection and transfer of classified information; and subversive activities and sabotage, including acts intended to disrupt or destroy infrastructure, transport facilities and enterprises. The decree did not create new offences; it merely restored the possibility of imposing the death penalty under existing provisions. Execution by shooting remained the only method. No precise public statistics are available on the number of people executed specifically under this decree: archival data are fragmentary, and records were kept by individual cases rather than by legislative act [7; 11].
The further development of capital punishment is associated with the 1960 Criminal Code of the RSFSR [12]. Some of its articles retained the possibility of imposing the death penalty for the same acts covered by the 1950 decree, while new offences were also added. Articles 66 and 67 covered terrorist acts, including the murder of a representative of a foreign state with the aim of provoking war or international complications. Article 68 established liability for sabotage, Article 77 for banditry, and Article 102 for premeditated murder under aggravating circumstances. Later, a law of 25 July 1962 expanded the list of offences to include certain economic crimes, such as large-scale violations of currency regulations and bribery, as well as some forms of rape. In practice, the death penalty was not mandatory; courts could impose it at their discretion as an alternative to imprisonment. Legal restrictions applied: capital punishment could not be imposed on persons who were under 18 at the time of the offence or on pregnant women, including women who became pregnant by the time the sentence was handed down or carried out. The institution of pardon, which fell within the competence of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR, played an important role. It made it possible to commute a death sentence to imprisonment, often for a term of up to 25 years, thereby reducing the number of executions actually carried out. Exact figures for executions under each individual article are not publicly available. However, aggregate estimates by researchers indicate that 2,159 people were sentenced to death in the RSFSR in 1962 alone. Between 1962 and 1989, approximately 24,422 death sentences were issued in the USSR, of which about 2,355 were commuted through pardons. Thus, approximately 22,000 people were actually executed. These figures reflect a combination of a strict legislative framework and variation in law enforcement, which depended on judicial practice and mechanisms for mitigating punishment [7; 11].
Contemporary Russia
A de facto moratorium on the death penalty has been in place in modern Russia since 1996. Its establishment was connected with Russia’s accession to the Council of Europe: on 28 February 1996, Russia became a member of the organization, one of the conditions of membership being the signing of Protocol No. 6 to the European Convention on Human Rights, which abolishes the death penalty in peacetime [13]. On 16 May 1996, President Boris Yeltsin signed the decree “On the Gradual Reduction of the Use of the Death Penalty in Connection with Russia’s Accession to the Council of Europe” [14]. The moratorium was not formally established by a separate statute. In practice, it began to operate because the head of state ceased considering applications for clemency. The last execution in modern Russia took place on 2 August 1996, when serial killer Sergey Golovkin was executed by shooting. Domestic legal arguments also played a role. Part 2 of Article 20 of the 1993 Constitution of the Russian Federation established the temporary nature of the death penalty: “until its abolition,” it may be imposed as an exceptional punishment for especially serious crimes against life, but only on condition that the case is heard by a court with the participation of a jury [15]. In 1999, in Ruling No. 3-P, the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation found that death sentences could not be handed down until jury trials had been introduced throughout the country [16]. At that time, jury trials operated only in certain regions, and the Court established a procedural barrier. The issue was not resolved even after jury trials were introduced in the last region, the Chechen Republic, in 2010. In 2009, the Constitutional Court clarified that, during the years in which the moratorium had been in force, stable guarantees of the human right not to be subjected to the death penalty had developed in Russia, together with a constitutional and legal framework aimed at the irreversible abolition of this punishment. The Court emphasized that the nationwide introduction of jury trials did not create an opportunity to reinstate capital punishment: the process of abolition had already become irreversible [17]. Even after Russia left the Council of Europe in 2022, the authorities maintained the position that the death penalty would not be applied. Instead, courts impose life imprisonment or a prison term of 25 years.
Results and Discussion
The analysis makes it possible to identify several stages in the development of the death penalty in Russia. Early legal sources treated it as a public measure of retribution and intimidation and prescribed it for a relatively limited range of serious offences, while later legislation expanded the list of offences and increasingly connected capital punishment with the protection of state authority.
The imperial period was not uniform: the Military Article of Peter I established a broad and severe system of capital sanctions, whereas the policies of Catherine II and Paul I reflected attempts to restrict their use. In the Soviet period, the legal status of the death penalty changed repeatedly in response to political circumstances: it was abolished in 1947 and restored in 1950, while subsequent criminal legislation retained it for specified serious offences.
The contemporary stage is characterised by the long-term non-application of capital punishment and by the constitutional and legal positions that have developed around this practice. The review therefore confirms that the history of the death penalty cannot be assessed solely through the wording of criminal statutes: its actual use was also shaped by political decisions, procedural safeguards and the possibility of clemency.
The historical material does not establish that the death penalty consistently reduced crime. It demonstrates instead that the scope and intensity of its application varied considerably between periods. Accordingly, the question of its effectiveness requires a separate empirical study and cannot be resolved by the historical and legal analysis undertaken in this article alone.
Conclusion
The history of the death penalty in Russia demonstrates the complex evolution of this institution: from an instrument of intimidation and retribution under the Pskov Judicial Charter and the Sudebnik of 1497 to a systematic means of state control during the imperial period, followed by a noticeable shift towards humanization under Catherine II and Paul I. In the Soviet era, the use of capital punishment changed repeatedly in response to political objectives: from abolition after the Revolution to a surge in repression in the 1930s, temporary abolition in 1947 and restoration in 1950. Certain restrictions were in force, including prohibitions on executing minors and pregnant women, and the institution of pardon was actively used. In contemporary Russia, the death penalty continues not to be applied: the moratorium is grounded in international commitments, constitutional provisions and the Constitutional Court’s position that the abandonment of this punishment is irreversible.
Thus, the history of the death penalty in Russian law reflects a movement away from reliance on retribution and intimidation towards recognition of the value of human life and legal safeguards. Historical experience shows that the effectiveness of capital punishment as a tool for combating crime has always been disputed, and its use was often determined not so much by the needs of justice as by the prevailing political situation. Today, the rejection of the death penalty represents not a temporary concession but a considered choice in favour of legal mechanisms that prevent irreversible miscarriages of justice and preserve the humanistic foundations of criminal law.
References
1. Beccaria, C. (1995). On Crimes and Punishments. 5th ed., revised and enlarged. Translated from Italian by Yu. M. Marinin and G. V. Cherdantsev; compiled by M. Yu. Yumashev. Moscow:
2. Catherine II. (1768). The Grand Instructions to the Commissioners Appointed to Frame a New Code of Laws for the Russian Empire.
3. Pskov Judicial Charter. In: Monuments of Russian Law. Issue 2: Monuments of Law of Feudal-Fragmented Rus, 12th–15th Centuries. Compiled by A. A. Zimin; edited by S. V. Yushkov. Moscow: Gosyurizdat, 1953.
4. Pskov First Chronicle. In: Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles. Vol. 4: Novgorod and Pskov Chronicles. Edited by the Archaeographical Commission. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya Pratsa, 1848.
5. Sudebnik of 1497. In: Monuments of Russian Law. Issue 3: Monuments of Law of the Period of Formation of the Russian Centralized State, 14th–15th Centuries. Moscow: Gosyurizdat, 1955.
6. Military Article of 1715. In: Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire. Collection 1. Vol. 5 (1713–1719). St. Petersburg, 1830.
7. Zhiltsov, S. V. (2002). The Death Penalty in the History of Russia. Moscow: IKD “Zertsalo-M”.
8. Criminal Code of the RSFSR, adopted on 26 May 1922. Collection of Laws and Regulations of the RSFSR. 1922. No. 15.
9. Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 26 May 1947 “On the Abolition of the Death Penalty”. Vedomosti Verkhovnogo Soveta SSSR. 1947. No. 17.
10. Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 12 January 1950 “On the Application of the Death Penalty to Traitors to the Motherland, Spies and Saboteurs”. In: Collection of Laws of the USSR and Decrees of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR, 1938–1958. Moscow, 1959.
11. Shishov, O. F. (1989). The Death Penalty in the History of Russia. In: The Death Penalty: For and Against. Compiled by O. F. Shishov and T. S. Parfenova; edited by S. G. Kelina. Moscow:
12. Criminal Code of the RSFSR of 27 October 1960. Vedomosti Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR. 1960. No. 40. Art. 591. [In Russian].
13. Protocol No. 6 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms concerning the Abolition of the Death Penalty. Strasbourg, 28 April 1983. European Treaty Series, No. 114
14. Decree of the President of the Russian Federation No. 724 of 16 May 1996 “On the Gradual Reduction of the Use of the Death Penalty in Connection with Russia’s Accession to the Council of Europe”.
15. Constitution of the Russian Federation, adopted by nationwide vote on 12 December 1993. Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 25 December 1993. No. 237.
16. Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation No. 3-P of 2 February 1999. Sobranie Zakonodatelstva Rossiyskoy Federatsii. 1999. No. 6.
17. Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation No. 1344-O-R of 19 November 2009. Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 27 November 2009. No. 226.
